![]()
How To Sell Board Games You No Longer Play can turn your unused collection into extra cash while making space for new games. Whether you’ve outgrown certain games or simply want to thin out your collection, there are multiple platforms and strategies to get good value for your board games.
The board game resale market has grown significantly, with collectors and new players constantly seeking both popular titles and rare finds. Knowing where to sell and how to price your games properly can make the difference between a quick sale and letting games sit unsold for months.
TL;DR
- BoardGameGeek marketplace typically gets you 60-70% of retail value for games in good condition.
- eBay auction-style listings often yield higher prices than Buy It Now for rare or popular games.
- Local Facebook Marketplace sales save you 10-13% in fees compared to online platforms.
- Games with all original components and minimal wear sell for 40-50% more than incomplete copies.
How To Sell Board Games You No Longer Play
The key to successful board game selling starts with proper preparation and choosing the right platform for each game. Different games perform better on different marketplaces depending on their popularity, rarity, and condition.
Start by sorting your games into categories – popular modern games, classic family board games, rare or out-of-print titles, and damaged or incomplete games. This helps you decide the best selling strategy for each category.
Our Favorite Posts
Preparing Your Games for Sale
Clean condition dramatically affects selling price and speed. Wipe down game boxes, organize components, and check for missing pieces before listing anything.
Take inventory of each game’s contents using the original rulebook or BGG component list. Missing pieces can cut your selling price in half, so be thorough in your checking.
Condition Assessment
Use standardized condition ratings to set realistic prices and attract serious buyers. Most platforms use similar grading systems.
- New in Shrink – unopened games command 85-95% of retail price.
- Like New – played once or twice with no visible wear, worth 70-80% of retail.
- Very Good – light play with minor box corner wear, typically 60-70% of retail.
- Good – moderate play with visible wear but all components present, 40-60% of retail.
- Fair/Poor – significant wear or missing components, 20-40% of retail or parts value only.
Best Online Platforms for Selling
Each platform has distinct advantages depending on your games and selling goals. Choose platforms based on your game types and how quickly you want to sell.
BoardGameGeek Marketplace
BGG’s marketplace connects you directly with serious board game collectors and enthusiasts. Games here often sell for higher prices because buyers understand true value.
The math auction system works well for rare games, while Buy It Now listings move popular titles quickly. Expect to pay $1 listing fees but reach the most targeted audience.
eBay
eBay reaches the largest audience but comes with 12-15% total fees between selling and payment processing. Auction-style listings can drive prices up for sought-after games.
Use Buy It Now for common games where you want predictable pricing. eBay works especially well for vintage games and complete collections.
Facebook Marketplace and Local Groups
Local selling eliminates shipping costs and fees while allowing buyers to inspect games before purchasing. Join local board game Facebook groups for access to engaged buyers.
Cash transactions mean immediate payment without waiting for checks or dealing with payment processing delays. Perfect for heavier games where shipping costs eat into profits.
Photography Tips
Take photos showing the box, opened game with all components visible, and any wear or damage. Good photos can increase selling prices by 20-30% compared to poor images.
Recommended Reading
- How to Use BoardGameGeek Complete BGG Guide for Beginners
- Board Game Podcasts Essential Listening for Tabletop Gaming Fans
- Trivia Party Games Testing Your Knowledge For Fun – Complete Guide
- Digital Invitations for Modern Game Nights Easy Planning Guide
- Free Printable Game Night Score Sheets for 20 Popular Games
- Game Night Ideas
Pricing Strategies That Work
Research completed sales rather than current listings to understand real market values. Check multiple platforms to see where similar games actually sold, not just listing prices.
Price competitively for quick sales or slightly higher if you’re willing to wait. Strategy board games often hold value better than party games or mass-market titles.
Timing Your Sales
List games during peak browsing times – Thursday through Sunday evenings typically see the most activity. Holiday seasons bring more buyers but also more competition.
Consider seasonal demand – party games sell better before holidays while heavy strategy games move better during winter months when people game more indoors.
Resources
- Free Printable Game Night Invitation Templates 10 Designs Ready to Print
- How to Find Local Board Game Groups and Game Cafes Near You
- Board Game Subscription Boxes Expert Picks Delivered Monthly
- Free Printable Trivia Questions for Your Next Game Night
- How to Buy Used Board Games Safely Complete Buyer’s Guide
Alternative Selling Methods
Local game stores sometimes buy collections, though expect to receive 25-35% of retail value. This works best when you want to sell many games quickly without individual listing work.
Gaming conventions often have flea markets or auction rooms where you can sell directly to attendees. Bring rare or popular games that will attract collector attention.
Trade vs. Sell Considerations
Trading on BGG or local groups can get you more value than cash sales. Use trades to upgrade to games you actually want rather than just clearing shelf space.
Some collectors prefer trades because they avoid tax implications and transaction fees while building relationships in the gaming community.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can I expect to get for used board games?
Most used board games in good condition sell for 50-70% of current retail price. Rare or out-of-print games may command higher percentages while mass-market games typically sell for less.
Should I sell games individually or as a lot?
Sell valuable games individually to maximize profit, but group lower-value games into themed lots. Individual sales take more work but typically yield 30-50% more than lot sales.
What if my game is missing pieces?
Clearly disclose missing components in your listing and price accordingly. Some buyers want games for parts or don’t mind minor missing pieces if the price reflects the condition.
How should I package games for shipping?
Use bubble wrap or packing paper to prevent box damage and secure loose components in bags. Consider the box as part of the game’s value – damaged boxes during shipping hurt your reputation.
Final Thoughts
How To Sell Board Games You No Longer Play successfully requires choosing the right platform, honest condition assessment, and competitive pricing. Focus on presentation and clear communication to build trust with buyers.
Start with a few games to learn the process before tackling your entire collection. The experience you gain from initial sales will help you price and market future games more effectively.
![]()
Subscribe to Our Newsletter